home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
- <text id=93TT0339>
- <title>
- Oct. 04, 1993: Now Who Rules Russia?
- </title>
- <history>
- TIME--The Weekly Newsmagazine--1993
- Oct. 04, 1993 On The Trail Of Terror
- </history>
- <article>
- <source>Time Magazine</source>
- <hdr>
- RUSSIA, Page 44
- Now Who Rules Russia?
- </hdr>
- <body>
- <p>In a bold bid for absolute power, Boris Yeltsin turned the lights
- out on parliament, but his hard-line rivals were not ready to
- concede
- </p>
- <p>By JOHN KOHAN/MOSCOW--With reporting by J.F.O. McAllister/Washington and William Mader/London
- </p>
- <p> The timing was a surprise, but not the act. For months Moscow
- had wondered when Boris Yeltsin would do it: take sole charge
- of Russia. Last week he did, dissolving the rebellious parliament,
- but his hard-line rivals did not slink off into the night. Now
- there are two Presidents, two Ministers of Defense, two Ministers
- of Security and two Ministers of the Interior. Two centers of
- government contend for power, one in the Kremlin and a second
- in Russia's White House, the seat of parliament. Both issued
- a flurry of orders and made separate appeals to Russia's 150
- million people to rally in support of two competing visions
- of the future of the nation.
- </p>
- <p> The political stalemate that had brought Russians much of the
- pain of reform without many of the benefits had finally gone
- on too long for Yeltsin. He had tried during the past 18 months
- of struggle with conservative lawmakers to abide by Russia's
- Soviet-era constitution while he pushed the go-slow parliament
- to adopt free-market changes. At times he came perilously close
- to overstepping the law. But he always beat a retreat, fearing
- that any challenge to the lawful order might destroy the state.
- </p>
- <p> A summer of paralysis took its toll. Yeltsin's economic-reform
- program was stuck, his authority under constant challenge, his
- time consumed in inconclusive dickering with his parliamentary
- opponents. Fed up, Yeltsin finally laid his claim to power on
- the line. In a prime-time television address Tuesday evening,
- he announced he was disbanding the legislature, even if it meant
- violating the constitution, and called new parliamentary elections
- for December. Angry Deputies quickly denounced Yeltsin's move
- as a coup d'etat and set up their own government, led by Vice
- President Alexander Rutskoi, Yeltsin's most implacable enemy.
- Suddenly, the most serious political crisis since the failed
- attempt to re-establish communist hegemony in August 1991 had
- engulfed Moscow.
- </p>
- <p> Yeltsin's gamble appeared to be paying off. Although citizens
- watched indifferently as political passions raged in and around
- the White House, parliament issued weapons to a motley band
- of supporters in the early hours of the conflict. On Thursday
- night eight armed men tried to break into a Moscow military
- facility. One policeman and an innocent bystander were killed.
- Yeltsin immediately ordered the Interior Ministry to confiscate
- weapons from the supposed defenders of the White House, and
- deployed hundreds of police, special forces and soldiers around
- the city. On Friday night columns of troops established a protective
- perimeter around the White House.
- </p>
- <p> Inside the building, a rump Congress of the People's Deputies
- began a hastily convened session by impeaching Yeltsin, but
- demoralized lawmakers were soon squabbling among themselves
- about whether to get rid of parliamentary chairman Ruslan Khasbulatov
- too. Yeltsin's government began to show signs of impatience
- with the siege, blocking access to the motor pool, keeping out
- fresh food supplies and, finally, turning off the electricity.
- As the crowds outside dwindled to several hundred diehards,
- groups of Deputies gathered by candlelight to plot their next
- move. But the standoff seemed all but over by week's end.
- </p>
- <p> Escape from communism into the brave new world of democracy
- is proving immensely difficult for all the pieces of the old
- Soviet Union. Yeltsin is not the only reformer who has found
- it nearly impossible to carry out change without violating constitutional
- norms. Georgian leader Eduard Shevardnadze, who earned his democratic
- credentials when he resigned as Soviet Foreign Minister in December
- 1990 to protest "coming dictatorship," also suspended his parliament
- this month to gain enough power to keep his tiny Caucasian mountain
- republic together. The question all across the former empire
- is whether democratic ends can really be achieved by less-than-democratic
- means.
- </p>
- <p> The West has shown sympathy and unanimous support for embattled
- reformers who have bent the rules, especially if the alternative
- is total chaos or a restoration of communist rule. After receiving
- personal assurances over the telephone from the Russian leader
- of his intention to hold free elections, President Clinton gave
- him a ringing endorsement. "I support him fully," said Clinton,
- adding that he was convinced Yeltsin would act in a way "that
- ensures peace, stability and an open political process."
- </p>
- <p> Continued support for Yeltsin will depend on how wisely he uses
- his newly assumed authority. Said a senior U.S. official: "It
- is the process, not the person, that we are supporting." Yeltsin
- got critical backing from Defense Minister Pavel Grachev and
- the military top brass, as well as from the police and security
- forces. Leaders from Russia's 88 regions and ethnic republics,
- where public opinion will ultimately decide which of the rival
- governments prevails, were still testing the winds from Moscow,
- but it seemed unlikely that they would risk supporting Rutskoi
- with the balance so clearly tilting in Yeltsin's favor.
- </p>
- <p> The morning after Yeltsin made his move, millions of ordinary
- Russians showed at least passive support by simply going about
- their business as if nothing had happened. The efforts of nationalists
- and neo-Bolsheviks to evoke the people power of August 1991
- and stir up passions against a coup were greeted by indifferent
- shrugs. "Why are they doing this?" asked a Moscow mechanic driving
- past the makeshift barriers. "No one is going to attack them.
- These communists can shout themselves hoarse for all I care.
- Yeltsin made the right decision."
- </p>
- <p> Yeltsin had been dropping broad hints in recent weeks that September
- would be "a month of battle." He shored up his strength in the
- hinterlands by inviting regional leaders to join a new consultative
- body called the Federation Council. Two weeks ago, he traveled
- to the suburban Moscow headquarters of the elite Dzerzhinsky
- division of Interior Ministry special forces, whose support
- would be vital for his plan.
- </p>
- <p> Announcing his dissolution order, the President baldly accused
- the parliament of "trying to push Russia into the abyss," declaring
- that the Deputies had "lost the right to remain at the levers
- of state power." Then, after theatrically pausing to sip from
- a cup of tea, he outlined plans to hold elections in December
- for one chamber of a new bicameral legislature, the Federal
- Assembly, that "would not engage in political games." As Yeltsin
- explained, "These measures are needed to protect Russia and
- the whole world against the catastrophic collapse of the Russian
- state and the reign of anarchy in a country possessing nuclear
- weapons."
- </p>
- <p> The parliament fought back at a hastily convened midnight session.
- Lawmakers appointed Rutskoi in Yeltsin's place under an article
- of the constitution that automatically strips the President
- of his powers if he suspends the activities of any legally elected
- organ of state power. Holding up a paperback edition of the
- much amended Russian constitution, Rutskoi, the Afghan War hero
- who was Yeltsin's handpicked running mate in the June 1991 elections,
- swore a new oath of allegiance and proclaimed his former mentor's
- decrees against the parliament null and void. Before the night
- was out, Rutskoi had named his own candidates to run the power
- ministries of Defense, Security and the Interior.
- </p>
- <p> The anti-Yeltsin revolt ran into trouble almost as soon as it
- began. Officials loyal to the elected President cut off special
- government telephone lines to the White House, making it all
- but impossible for Rutskoi to establish reliable communications
- with supporters in the provinces. The state television network,
- under Yeltsin's control, refused to carry live coverage of the
- parliamentary session, fitting events from the White House into
- pro-Yeltsin broadcasts. Despite an appeal from Khasbulatov for
- the army and police to disobey Kremlin orders, Rutskoi's newly
- appointed Minister of Defense, General Vladislav Achalov, could
- not even gain entry to Russia's Pentagon.
- </p>
- <p> Yeltsin tried to bolster his image as a winner by taking Defense
- Minister Grachev and Interior Minister Victor Yerin along on
- a brief walkabout in central Moscow. Mingling with the cheering
- crowds, the President explained that he was already at work
- setting up electoral commissions for the December vote. He laughed
- off any suggestion of compromise with the parliament. "It does
- not exist, so there is not, cannot and must not be any dialogue,"
- he said. "I think we have had enough of parliament making fools
- of us." Yeltsin did not say how he planned to bring the standoff
- with parliament to an end, but promised that there would be
- "no blood."
- </p>
- <p> Even if the Kremlin does succeed in dispersing the parliament,
- the future is far too uncertain for Yeltsin to claim victory.
- With the leaders of the August 1991 coup still involved in a
- drawn-out trial, the Kremlin will hardly want to begin another
- political spectacle by arresting Rutskoi, Khasbulatov and other
- leaders of the anti-Yeltsin revolt and creating a new group
- of martyrs for the hard-liners. Nor are rank-and-file legislators
- likely to depart Moscow in silence. Support for Yeltsin in the
- provinces is soft enough that parliamentary dissidents might
- be able to stir up plenty of trouble before a December vote.
- </p>
- <p> Yeltsin cannot be certain that all will remain quiet in the
- military either. Unit commanders in the Russian army may have
- affirmed their loyalty, but regional mutinies might flare up,
- led by officers angered at the breakdown of the once mighty
- Soviet armed forces. "There are forces trying to bring officers
- to the barricades against each other," Grachev conceded last
- week. "If the officer corps splits and takes up arms, this could
- be the start of a genuine civil war."
- </p>
- <p> The Russian leader took pains to demonstrate that business was
- not just going on as usual at the Kremlin: he wanted to show
- that the pace of decision making had picked up dramatically
- without a parliament to thwart him. Yeltsin has reappointed
- Yegor Gaidar, the original architect of his economic reforms,
- to the government, signaling his intent to move back to a more
- radical course. He played host to an economic summit of leaders
- from the Commonwealth of Independent States, who pledged him
- their support. He confirmed central-bank chairman Victor Gerashchenko
- while taking control of the country's main financial operation,
- formerly subservient to the parliament. Yeltsin even displayed
- a willingness to put his own political future on the line by
- moving up the date for presidential elections from 1996 to June
- 1994.
- </p>
- <p> Yeltsin's greatest challenge will be to demonstrate that he
- can govern effectively by presidential decree for the next 11
- weeks. That may not seem like a long time, but on Russia's troubled
- calendar, it can be a political eternity. Should he falter with
- his reforms now, he will no longer be able to blame parliamentary
- opposition when critics complain that his policies have done
- little more than promote corruption and impoverish the population.
- Yeltsin may just find himself confronting a new parliament that
- is every bit as ornery as the old one.
- </p>
-
- </body>
- </article>
- </text>
-
-